Creditor Claims: Allowance, Rejection and Suit
A California personal representative must allow or reject every creditor claim in writing and notify the creditor. A rejected claim is then barred unless the creditor sues within 90 days — a deadline that runs whatever the ordinary statute of limitations would have allowed.
Two clocks, and they are different
Estate creditor work runs on two separate deadlines that get confused constantly. The first is the window to file a claim at all — under section 9100 that is the later of four months after letters issue or sixty days after notice of administration reaches the creditor, and it is covered on the timeline page. The second, dealt with here, only starts once a filed claim has been rejected: ninety days to sue. A creditor who files on time and then waits to negotiate can still lose everything by letting the second clock run out.
What the representative must do
Probate Code section 9250 makes the response mandatory and formal. When a claim is filed the personal representative shall allow or reject it, in whole or in part, in writing, file that allowance or rejection with the court clerk, and give notice to the creditor together with a copy. The statute prescribes the contents: the creditor’s name, the total amount of the claim, the date letters issued, the date of death, the estimated value of the estate, the amount allowed or rejected, whether the representative is authorised under the Independent Administration of Estates Act, and a statement that the creditor has ninety days in which to act on a rejected claim. Section 9353 supplies the consequence. Regardless of whether the otherwise applicable statute of limitations would expire sooner or later, a rejected claim is barred as to the rejected part unless within ninety days of the notice the creditor commences an action, or the matter is referred to a referee or to arbitration.
Sources: Probate Code s.9250 - Allowance or rejection of a creditor claim · Probate Code s.9353 - Ninety days to sue on a rejected claim · Probate Code s.9100 - Time for a creditor to file a claim · Verified 2026-08-20.
The sequence
| Step | Who acts | Deadline |
|---|---|---|
| File the claim | Creditor | Later of 4 months from letters, or 60 days from notice — §9100 |
| Allow or reject, in writing | Personal representative | §9250 — no fixed period, but required |
| Notice of rejection served | Personal representative | With a copy, to the creditor |
| Sue, or refer to arbitration | Creditor | 90 days from notice — §9353 |
| Claim not yet due when rejected | Creditor | 90 days from when it becomes due |
Why the ninety days overrides everything
Section 9353 opens with the words that matter: regardless of whether the statute of limitations otherwise applicable will expire before or after. A creditor holding a written contract with four years left on it does not get four years. Once the rejection notice is served, ninety days is the whole of it. The only pause the statute recognises is a vacancy in the office of personal representative, which is excluded from the count.
Reading it from the estate’s side
For a personal representative the rejection is a tool, not a formality. Rejecting a doubtful claim in writing starts a short clock that most marginal creditors will not fund a lawsuit to beat. Allowing a claim that should have been examined, by contrast, is a decision beneficiaries can later question, and paying it is the kind of act a surcharge analysis reaches. Section 9250 also asks whether the representative acts under the IAEA, which ties back to what can be done without court supervision.
Where these become disputes
Claims filed by the personal representative themselves, or by family members asserting loans nobody documented, are the recurring flashpoints. So are medical and long-term care claims arriving late in administration. When a beneficiary believes debts were paid that should have been challenged, or a creditor believes a valid debt was rejected to protect the family, the argument lands in contested probate.
Related: the four-month filing window, the representative’s duties, and the administration process.